Which of our income can we claim Gift Aid on?
- Time1–2 weeks
- CostFree for straightforward cases; advice for membership or sponsorship structures
- Doing itGet help with this
Only a gift of money from an individual, given under a valid declaration, qualifies as a Gift Aid donation. Some things that feel like donations are not: event and raffle tickets never qualify. Membership fees usually fail unless they buy voting rights and AGM attendance and nothing more. Where the donor gets too much back, a separate test applies, covered in Step 7.
Do this first
England and Wales: This page sets out the position in full — Gift Aid eligibility is a UK-wide tax question and does not vary by nation. Scotland: the same position for Gift Aid itself. Where income runs through a commercial participator’s agreement, though, the charity-law regime behind that agreement is a different Scottish one, not the England and Wales rule named below. Northern Ireland: the same position, with no difference in principle.
What makes a payment a Gift Aid donation?
A payment is a Gift Aid donation only if it is a gift, not payment for services, rights or goods. A Gift Aid donation is a gift of money from an individual, made under a valid declaration. The rule comes from the Income Tax Act 2007, as HMRC’s guidance applies it. It is the same in England and Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland.
HMRC’s basic rule is a single sentence. Almost every hard case in this hub is that sentence applied to one kind of income:
“Payments to a charity in return for services, rights or goods are not gifts to charity and so are not eligible for the Gift Aid Scheme.”
An ordinary cash gift, with nothing supplied in return, passes. Everything below is what happens at the edge of that sentence.
The page assumes you have designed a compliant Gift Aid declaration. It also assumes income is recorded by type and source, which follows from determining which accounts to prepare. The terms each funder gives on are the funding hub’s subject, from writing the monitoring and evaluation section onwards.
Which income qualifies for Gift Aid: the working table
The table classifies the ten types of income that come up again and again. Nine are settled, and cited to HMRC’s own wording. The tenth — sponsored challenge events — is left open on purpose.
The rules on a charity covering part of a participant’s own costs have not been read closely enough to publish a row for it. A guessed answer here would be worse than an honest gap.
| Income | Gift Aid? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Ordinary cash donation | Yes | A voluntary gift, with nothing supplied in return. |
| Event tickets | No | Payment for a right of admission. A separate, genuinely voluntary donation on top of the ticket price can still qualify. |
| Lottery, raffle and “100 club” tickets | No | Payment for the right to enter a draw, not a gift — the same basic rule quoted above. |
| Membership subscriptions | Sometimes | Qualifies only where it secures voting rights and the right to attend the AGM, and buys nothing more than membership. Newsletters about the charity’s work do not count against it. A subscription bought merely to receive a magazine does not qualify. |
| Charity auction | Partly | Two conditions, both required: the item can be bought separately elsewhere, and the donor knows its value at the time of the winning bid. |
| Sponsored challenge events | Not yet settled | The rules on a charity covering part of a participant’s own costs have not been checked, so this row is left open — do not treat it as a “yes” or a “no”. |
| Church and street cash collections | Yes, with a declaration | Without one it may fall under the small donations scheme instead. |
| Goods donated to a charity shop | Not directly | What is given is the net sale proceeds, not the item — a separate mechanism, retail Gift Aid. |
| Corporate sponsorship | Usually no | If advertising or another benefit is supplied in return, it is trading income — see the business sponsorship section. |
| Payment for services, rights or goods | No | HMRC’s basic rule, from which every row follows. |
Membership subscriptions and charity auctions
The membership row turns on a positive gateway, not only on what the subscription must avoid. HMRC’s own wording:
“…membership subscriptions paid to charities that secure voting rights and the right to attend a charity’s Annual General Meeting (AGM) are gifts provided they meet the conditions in the next paragraph.”
Voting rights plus AGM attendance is the gate. A subscription that buys neither does not pass, whatever else it offers. And a subscription bought purely to receive a magazine “is the purchase of a magazine subscription and cannot be gift aided” — HMRC’s own words. Worth having ready, next time a member asks why their subscription was not claimed on.
The auction row has a similarly precise test, and it is not the one most guidance describes. HMRC’s own wording:
“For auction items, this treatment only applies where: the auction item can be purchased separately elsewhere / the donor is aware of the value of the benefit (the retail cost of the item) at the time they make their successful auction bid (donation).”
Both conditions are required together. An announcement to the room before bidding starts is one way of meeting the second condition. It is not the test itself, and nothing requires it specifically.
Two hard limits follow from the first condition. An item that cannot be bought anywhere else is valued at whatever the auction raised for it, so none of that price is Gift Aid-able. And a celebrity-signed or celebrity-donated item is valued at what it fetches at auction, not at what an equivalent unsigned item would cost.
When does business sponsorship become trading income?
Business sponsorship can become trading income, not a donation, when the charity itself publicises its link with the sponsor. A payment from a local business feels like a donation. It is given willingly, and the business expects little back. HMRC’s test turns on something more specific than intention — who does the publicising:
“The fact that the business sponsor itself takes steps to publicise or exploit the affinity with the charity will not change the treatment of the payments in the hands of the charity, unless the charity also publicises the affinity itself.”
A sponsor shouting about its own generosity does not touch the charity’s tax treatment. What converts the payment into trading income is the charity joining in — a large, prominent logo, the sponsor’s corporate colours, a description of its products. The tax treatment is then entirely different, and the page on tax on trading income takes it from there.
Where the arrangement runs through a formal commercial participator agreement, charity law adds a separate requirement on top of the tax question. In England and Wales the business may say contributions will go to the charity only under a written agreement signed by both sides. HMRC’s guidance adds that where such an agreement is in place before the sponsor pays, its wording decides the tax treatment.
Without one, the facts decide. One more reason to get the wording right before the money moves, not after.
Can a donation that funds a loan back to the donor qualify?
No. A donation that funds a loan back to the donor, or to someone connected with them, does not qualify for Gift Aid. A First-tier Tribunal case is the origin of this point.
How it should be cited matters as much as what it decided. The tribunal’s own text sits outside this project’s permitted source tiers. HMRC’s own account of the case, at Chapter 3.13.3 of its guidance, does not — so that is what this page cites, not the judgment itself:
“The act of making the loan was enough to break the limits defining a qualifying donation for Gift Aid purposes which are set out at S416 ITA 2007. The judge found that: … the benefit arising to the borrower in such an arrangement is equivalent to the full amount loaned … conditions E and F of S416 ITA 2007 had not been met and the original donation did not qualify for Gift Aid relief.”
The statutory basis is specific — Income Tax Act 2007 s.416, Conditions E and F — not a general anti-abuse rule. Condition E, in the Act’s own words:
“the payment is not conditional on, associated with or part of an arrangement involving, the acquisition of property by the charity from the individual or a person connected with the individual.”
A donation that finances a loan back to the donor, or to someone connected with them, fails that condition on its own facts. The loan is treated as a benefit to the borrower equal to its full amount. Set against the donor-benefit limits, that is not a small benefit that might scrape under a threshold — it is total.
A donation may be offered on terms that involve lending money back to the donor or a connected person. If so, stop and take advice before accepting it.
Donor benefits: the separate test in Step 7
Some income fails a different test entirely. It is a gift, but the donor gets too much back for giving it.
That test has its own thresholds, its own aggregation rule across a tax year, and its own trap for membership schemes paid other than annually. This page names the boundary; it does not do the arithmetic. Once the income is classified, the next step — what you can give donors in return without losing Gift Aid — is where that work happens.
Common mistake: treating sponsorship as a donation because it came from a supportive local business
The money is given willingly, and the business expects little in return. It feels like a gift. If the charity itself publicises the affinity — a prominent logo, the sponsor’s colours, a description of its products — the payment can become trading income. The tax treatment changes entirely, regardless of how willingly the money was given.
Common mistake: claiming on a donation that funds a loan back to someone connected with the donor
The donation and the loan look like two separate transactions. The arrangement can seem like a convenience rather than a circularity. HMRC treats the loan itself as a benefit to the borrower equal to its full amount. That fails the statutory conditions for a qualifying donation outright.
Worked example
A local business gives Tollgate Youth CIO money towards its summer programme, and Tollgate puts the sponsor’s logo on the programme booklet. A small, discreet acknowledgement does not change anything — the payment is still a gift.
A large, prominent logo in the sponsor’s own colours, alongside a line describing its products, is different. It tips the same payment into advertising, and the tax treatment changes with it. Tollgate’s rule of thumb: decide which side of that line a sponsorship sits on, and record the reasoning, before the money arrives, not after.
What you should have at the end
A written classification of each income stream as Gift Aid eligible or not, with reasons.
"With reasons" is what makes the document worth having. A bare yes/no list tells a reviewer nothing about whether the classification was thought through. A line of reasoning against each entry does. An income classification record template and a Gift Aid eligibility checker are planned. Until either is available, build the record directly from the working table.
Common questions
No. Gift Aid applies only to gifts of money from individuals, given under a valid declaration. A payment from a business is not a Gift Aid donation. Where the charity itself publicises its link with the business, the payment can become trading income instead, with a different tax treatment.
Not directly. Gift Aid applies to gifts of money, so donated goods do not qualify as they stand. Where goods are sold in a charity shop, what is given is the net sale proceeds. The separate route for that is set out in Step 11, Set up retail Gift Aid.